New Americana | Food Delivery - Eureka, California

erin P.

His flavor combinations are amazing. Like the Midnight moon Mac and cheese is super yummy. The Brussels sprouts are bomb!!! Cooked just how I like them. The polenta is always friend to perfection! This place is amazing, I hope to see more from them in the future!

Emily K.

Words cannot describe this place...it is absolutely phenomenal! I got the sweet tomato salad and I'm pretty sure it's the best thing I've ever eaten. the produce is so fresh, you can tell it was made with love. I also tried the Manchego Mac N Cheese my boyfriend got and holy moly, it's amazing. you HAVE to stop here to eat, you will not regret it. There's limited options but there's something for everyone...everything on the menu is so thought out and amazing, you can't go wrong.

Evan R.

I was a little unsure about ordering from this place because it was new and only had a few reviews BUT I am so impressed with how it turned out! The salad had a great combination of flavors, the MacNCheese was creamy and just was out of this world DELICIOUSNESS! Highly recommend for a late night munch fest or an easy dinner. I thought it was well priced for the quality of food and portions. Overall 5/5 would recommend.
I normally post on Yelp, but been having some issues with the app.

Robert K.

10 stars out of 5. Seth, the owner, is a great guy, makes great food, and has a great business. If you are stopping by Eureka or the surrounding areas, or are just looking for something new to try out, DEFINITELY come to New Americana in Eureka, CA. Definitely excited to see this little shop grow: Seth, if you’re reading this, 10 stars out of 5, you’re the man and keep doing what you’re doing.

EDIT: Me and my girlfriend were on our way back to Santa Barbara, CA from Seattle, and had not been pleased with the foods we chose on the way up. However, after stumbling across Seth’s New Americana, we might just have found a reason to stay another night. After enjoying some “california freedoms”, I dug into my Manchego Mac.... I got goosebumps. Phenomenal food! Cannot stress enough. Even though the menu is traditionally small, there is something for literally everyone and it is crafted with perfection. Thank you for making our stay in Eureka 100000 stars out of 10

Ray M.

Ordered a nice selection for New Years Eve from Door Dash. We chose the Polenta Sticks, Ponzu Brussel Sprouts and of course, the corn dogs. Out of all three, the Ponzu Sprouts were our favorite for sure! Also of note, Seth (owner/chef) is a great guy, have talked with him and met his dog a few times around Old Town. Quality food and $ goes towards supporting a local with the right intentions.

John D.

Absolutely phenomenal, must order the brussel sprouts! the mac and cheese was the best I've had and the polenta has a perfectly crunchy outside and smooth polenta inside!

Michael K.

The owner and chef of this restaurant is very down to earth and cooks up some amazing meals! Just after one night he's earned a repeat customer from me. I'd recommend to anyone in the Humboldt County area.

Hayley

The Mac and cheese is to die for!! I absolutely love it. Such an amazing place with great vibes all the way around. Would definitely recommend