Martha's Leelanau Table - Suttons Bay, Michigan

Carol O.

We first visited four years ago while traveling. It was really one of the best dining experiences we’ve had. We sat outside. They had live music, wonderful food and service. A delightful evening. We are going back next week and are truly looking forward to it.

Lynn ?.

Have not had a bad meal here ever. Can't say that about many places. Lovely home setting with outdoor patio area as well. The menu and food cannot be beat. Love that they take reservations. Always fun to stroll downtown Suttons Bay and the free street parking is a plus. Highly recommend.

Alisha M.

The food and ambiance on the patio was absolutely amazing. The musicians were incredible on Friday night and made our night at Martha’s even more special! Definitely coming back here anytime we visit Sutton Bay.

Adrianna R.

The experience at Martha’s was truly a treat! I stumbled across an Open sign on a Sunday evening (on Mother’s Day!) without a reservation and was promptly offered the first available table by a cozy fire pit outside by the wonderful hostess. The live music was lovely, the service was just, impeccable! And the food… I can’t wait to return to try everything on the menu. Thank you so much for making my long road trip feel so warm and inviting. Truly a surprise treat.

Sketchy P.

Our dinner was great - make that reservation - the food is very fresh and very flavorful! I am usually so so about dessert but consider getting one of these desserts. They are delicious I had a tiramisu that rivaled some of my favorite places in New York. I got so excited I forgot to take a picture of it. Friends had the coconut cream pie and homemade ice cream sundae. All very tasty.

Brian H.

We had the calamari and halibut. Chef Rob came out to ask us our opinion on each course and informed us about where the food was sourced and how it was prepared. Our server David was very attentive and gave us great recommendations for the area. The food was delicious and the experience was one we will not forget being visitors to town. Highly recommend!

Danom7

The prices definitely did not meet the quality of what was served, the food was just mediocre blah I don’t even want to waste time to describe the food.

Our server was great!

But!! Martha herself is a not a pleasant person not sure if she’s going through something or she’s like that all the time. She gives off this insipid vibe, similar to the food, so meta, maybe this is what the place is going for. I run into people like her at restaurants all the time, but if their food is amazing they get a pass for being jerks and I eventually become friends with them, but at Martha’s Table i don’t need to go back the only good thing was the server.

Zachary G.

Absolutely amazing date night. Great staff and a thoughtfully designed, well prepared meal. We don’t have any dietary restrictions, but the menu was very accommodating if we did. We tried the vegan scallops, and would recommend them to anyone. They were absolutely delicious and not a crumb was spared. Even if you’re just looking for dessert, the carrot cake here is the best I have ever eaten. Most carrot cake is just an excuse to eat cream cheese frosting, but this was much more. Martha’s carrot cake was moist, well balanced in spice and sweetness, and left me wanting more the next night!