Nutini's Supper Club - Hancock, Michigan

Martha

Nutini's has the best pizza! There are several vegetarian pizza options. My favorites are the Mediterranean and the Potato Feta. The service is friendly and attentive, and I love the retro vibe of the place. Prices are very reasonable. If you order pizza, expect a wait, but it is worth it. Booths could use some updating, they are in pretty rough shape, but otherwise a great, low key spot for a delicious meal.

Megzie M.

Good service, friendly staff and awesome pizza! Highly recommend the sourdough crust with anything on it. I will say, as for dine-in, it could use a little upkeep but I love low key places like this!

Amy J.

We sat down at 6:40 on a Saturday night. It was clear that they had a large party coming in, but that was not mentioned to us. There were 2 or 3 other tables filled at the time. We ordered an appetizer (took 20 minutes) and 2 entrees. We finished the appetizer, and then 10 minutes later were asked by a waitress (not ours) if we had also ordered food. At that point, we needed to leave in 25 minutes. We said yes, and I waited another 15 minutes for my salad. At that point, we asked for our entrees to be boxed up, as we had to leave. We then waited another 20 minutes for our entrees. When the check came, we were charged a "non-cash adjustment", despite the fact that we paid in cash.

When we got home and finally ate our food, my husband's sandwich had peppers on it (he specifically chose something without peppers because they don't agree with him at all). The sandwich also was 75% bread with very little substance. My baked potato did not have the butter or sour cream that I ordered.

Michael S.

Hidden gem , come get the sour dough crust pizza, or any one of their great menu items. Jamie is a great cook and rachel was an awesome bar tender. Thanks for the dinner, I'll be back. They also do take out, give them a try.

Jenny M.

My daughter loves coming here for the spaghetti every time we come visit the Copper Country! My mom went here when she was younger and said the recipe for their spaghetti hasn't changed since they opened and the waitress confirmed this. It brought her back to her childhood as soon as she took her first bite! The club sandwich, spaghetti, and meatball sandwich were all what we ordered and they were delicious! Even the side salad was yummy! We go here at least once because my daughter raves about it when we're back home!
The service is quite slow, but we are on vacation so we just enjoyed each other's company and the waitress was very kind and gave us a discount. We were there 2 hours, but it was ok. There was only 1 cook and the waitress, but she was helping him in the back. They are very friendly and welcoming! If you have time, I would definitely visit this place!

Minnema I.

Excellent pizza & great atmosphere. Solid tap beer options. Classy place, really enjoyed it.

Laurel G.

Delicious pizza on a sourdough crust and friendly service on a busy evening

Jessica O.

The seafood Alfredo was terrible. It was like they poured a can of shrimp on it then a can of chicken gravy.

The men’s bathroom was disgustingly dirty. No door on the stall.